Dave Winer and Vidya Lakshmipathy have taken opposite sides in the discussion about the mobile web experience.
The question is whether the iPhone experience of the "full internet" is better for mobile devices or do we need an optimized version of the web for mobile devices.
Dave thinks we will always need a well designed mobile web sites because the screen will always be the limiting factor. Even with a gorgeous iPhone screen he thinks it's too much work to zoom in & out, scrolling up/down/left/right.
Vidya disagrees. She is a fan of the iPhone view of the world.
I agree with Dave but for a different reason.
The problem is the network - not the screen/resolution anymore. The user experience depends on whether you are browsing on a fast/WiFi network or on a slow network like AT&T's EDGE network.
The full internet is awesome on the iPhone if you are on a Wifi network. However, surfing the full internet is unusable if you are using EDGE. That's when I point my iPhone browser to mobile websites like m.twitter.com, m.facebook.com, flickr's mobile site or the mobile version of Outlook Web Access.
I have two sets of bookmarks on my iPhone. Full websites when I'm on WiFi. And stripped down, mobile websites when i'm on Edge.
Once we have faster cellular data networks and/or open WiFi in more places I'm going to be in Vidya's camp.
And I'm hoping that day happens soon.